Home / Carolina Forest / The Politics Of Dirty Flood Waters
Tom Rice
SC Politicians: Tom Rice, Heather Ammons Crawford, Mayor Brenda Bethune, Mark Lazarus, Cam Crawford, Russell Fry

The Politics Of Dirty Flood Waters

The Waccamaw River runs 140 miles from its starting point in Lake Waccamaw, NC to where it meets the ocean in Winyah Bay at Georgetown, S.C.   The river is as old as time itself. The waters likely were named by the Waccamaw indians. The language is now a dead tongue. No one living can tell us the significance of the name.

The river snakes a good portion of its initial way alongside Highway 905.  It reaches the S.C. border in a location known as Longs, S.C.  Footage taken by the Horry County Police Department shows the massive fish kill that happened along that stretch of river.  A depletion of oxygen in the water killed these fish. Oxygen depletion was caused by compounding factors that include contaminants found in the water by the Department of Health And Environmental Control.  Authorities ask all residents not to eat fish caught in flood waters.


Estimates are that up to 2,100 homes were flooded along the Waccamaw River and the Intracoastal Waterway (which the Waccamaw feeds into).

THE WACCAMAW FLOODS HIT CONWAY

On September 26th, The Sun News reported: The Grand Strand Water and Sewer Authority notified the S.C. Department of Health and Environmental Control on Wednesday, September 26th,  that its Conway Wastewater Treatment Plant is not currently operational due to flooding from Hurricane Florence.   Untreated wastewater is now being discharged into a tributary that feeds into the Waccamaw River.

Citizens are advised to avoid all contact with water around and downstream of the facility, which is located at 2915 New Road, near the corner of Creel Street across Lake Busbee from U.S. 501.  DHEC recommends citizens minimize contact with all flood waters including impacted rivers and streams. There are many health concerns including infectious diseases, diarrheal diseases, wound infections and chemicals, and safety concerns including drowning, injuries, electrical hazards and bites from animals and insects including snakes, floating balls of fire ants and other wildlife.

CONWAY’S LAKE BUSBEE, SANTEE COOPER,  AND COAL ASH POLITICS

On September 24th, our news team flew a drone over the Santee Cooper Grainger facility.  There are two coal ash ponds at that location.  The plant was closed in 2012.  The EPA required Santee Cooper to remove all of the coal ash from the facility as coal ash breaks down into heavy metals when it gets into the river.  The heavy metals and arsenic produced by the ash are known environmental hazards.  In carefully worded language, Santee Cooper claims Ash Pond 1 is free of coal ash.  Ash Pond 2, says Waccamaw River Keeper, still has 200,000 tons of coal ash.

We reached out to the environment group, Waccamaw River Keeper,  about the above documented breach on Ash Pond 1. Here is their response.  “It’s very sad but we don’t have any reason to believe there’s Coal Ash in the Waccamaw River. Pond 1 had no ash in it and that’s the one that overtopped. Pond 2 has 200,000 tons of coal ash and we anticipate if it rises to 21.3 feet it may over top but that has not happened yet.

We asked Waccamaw River Keeper:  What records have been produced that can verify Ash Pond 1 had no coal ash?  Waccamaw River Keeper replied, “Pond 1 is not officially certified clean. However they had removed the coal ash and were in the process of excavating the top foot of soil from the pond as required. That soil is considered clean and can be reused for other projects.

We then asked: Who considered it clean?  Are there documents we can see/publish?  Said Waccamaw River Keeper,  “Five years ago we won in court to get Santee Cooper remove the coal ash and have been monitoring their activities and analyze all water quality impacts at that site as it relates to the Waccamaw and have been for many years.”  No documentation was produced nor offered.

We were able to find a copy of the lawsuit online.  https://dms.psc.sc.gov/Attachments/Matter/9ff8a34b-155d-141f-23ac35b9bdcbe64f    Santee Cooper settled the case.  One troubling clause we found in the document was this item:  No Third Party Beneficiaries. This Agreement is not for the benefit of any person other than the parties and gives no rights or remedies to any third parties.   (The Waccamaw River is a key source of Horry County drinking water.  The third parties in question would be the actual people who drink the water. )

LEGISLATORS QUIET,  EXCEPT ONE OUTSPOKEN MAYOR

We reached out to all of the top pictured above.  We also reached out to S.C. Governor Henry McMaster.  We wanted documented proof that Coal Ash Pond 1 was certified clean.  None responded, except Mayor Brenda Bethune.   Despite the video footage above, and the mayor’s citing Santee Cooper as the authority expert on the matter, Mayor Bethune stated on Facebook.

Santee Cooper
Nice Picture, But Fox Guarding Hen House?

PROBLEMS WITH TRUSTING SANTEE COOPER

Santee Cooper then made a declaration in the comments on our own video:  Santee Cooper stated: There is no breach in the dikes around either ash pond at Grainger. As we said on Saturday, the Waccamaw River has overtopped Pond 1, where nearly all of the ash has already been excavated. It has not overtopped Pond 2 yet, although the NOAA forecast model shows that it could. Overtopping does not mean the dikes will breach or that ash will be released. Most importantly, we are also testing the river water and sediment twice a day, and other entities including DHEC, the Waccamaw Riverkeeper and downstream water users are conducting their own testing. Current testing results do not indicate the presence of any elevated constituents in the river. Those results will indicate if there is any release, and if so, those results will guide our response. We will keep the public informed as we continue to work through this unprecedented flooding event. Here is additional information:

https://waterkeeper.org/waterkeeper-responds-to-the…/   (NOTE THE UTILITY’S SOURCE OF WACCAMAW RIVERKEEEPER)

https://www.santeecooper.com/…/092418-Santee-Cooper…

MyrtleBeachSC news noted that Santee Cooper’s language above says NEARLY ALL OF THE ASH HAS ALREADY BEEN EXCAVATED.  Why the ongoing change in nuanced language?

The failed V.C. Summer nuclear project: A timeline

CHOOSE ENERGY published the following timeline on Santee Cooper and SCANNA’s $8 billion dollar failure.   https://www.chooseenergy.com/news/article/failed-v-c-summer-nuclear-project-timeline/

It has been hard for the media to draw a line between where Santee Cooper’s board ends and where elected politicians begin in this process.  It appears they are all neck deep in this together. As the ship at Santee Cooper continues to go down, multi-million dollar (lifetime) golden parachutes have been continually extended to most all top level Santee Cooper executives.

As to accountability,  MyrtleBeachSC news finds it practically impossible to get any elected official to mouth the words Santee Cooper.  None of the above, except Bethune, were willing to go public when we asked.  Behtune’s jurisdictional credibility is entirely questionable here.

The below is what State Representative Kevin Hardee posted concerning Governor McMaster’s email to Santee Cooper’s James Brogdon Jr. on September 16th:

THE FLOODS REACH SOCASTEE

What’s in your garage and cabinets?  Any rat poisoning, roach spray, fertilizer, or other bio hazards tucked away there?  Each of these homes in Socastee were evacuated and flooded.

ON TO THE OCEAN

DHEC advised against swimming in the ocean at Myrtle Beach and North Myrtle Beach.  The City of North Myrtle Beach put out a similar advisory.  The City of Myrtle Beach did not.

We reached out to four highly credited Marine Biologists.  None were willing to speak “officially” on the record about water quality and beach water quality.  Apparently state and federal grants which support research are a primary consideration for these experts.

As we stated, since our drinking water comes from the Waccamaw River, we wanted to get at least one credible politician on the record with certification the river was clean.  One non-official bureaucrat stated: “You are scaring people unnecessarily.  Not one resident, including you, has come forward with proof that the river is contaminated.”

Other than Bethune’s comment, nothing else was said. MyrtleBeachSC news has been “assured” that Grand Strand Water and Sewer can treat whatever contaminants are in the water making it 100% drinkable.

Most all of the politicians listed above were willing to express concerns about the urgent need for using FEMA dollars to help pay for I-73.   Portions of that future interstate were under water during Hurricane Florence.

 

Comments

comments

About David Hucks

Born in 1961, David is a 12th generation descendant of the area we now call Myrtle Beach, S.C. David attended Coastal Carolina University and like most of his family, has never left the area. David is the lead journalist at MyrtleBeachSC.com

Check Also

E District

Will New “E” District Change Surfside Beach?

Surfside Beach City Council and Mayor Bob Childs voted to approve the Surfside Beach “E” …